{"schema_version":"legis-intel-library-graph/1","record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","facsimile_relationships":[],"coverage":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","outbound":["citation-e7821653ceacc1060257","citation-bbeeea8ff31ec40d2175","citation-591a7adbe8deb363f44f"],"inbound":[],"internal":["internal-2a00baf21c86a99d0e02"],"external_outgoing":[],"external_incoming":[],"unresolved":["citation-591a7adbe8deb363f44f","unresolved-07983fdc8f33f22a25cc","unresolved-48990c85fcf924fc42eb"],"status":"source_citations_examined","resolved_outbound":2,"resolved_internal":1},"citations":[{"id":"citation-e7821653ceacc1060257","source":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","target":"punjab-code-c556bd2d4070a8e6","target_candidates":["punjab-code-c556bd2d4070a8e6"],"resolution":"exact_title_match","relation":"explicit_instrument_citation","evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":3745,"character_end":3777,"quote":"Punjab Civil Servants Act , 1974","quote_sha256":"90546ba2e9a21952a88e6b48a4756be02d4fea49e66d5c90205389d725b71b16","reader_fragment":"p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"},"context_evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":3575,"character_end":4007,"quote":"ichever is later, prefer an appeal to the Tribunal: \r\n Provided that– \r\n(a) where an appeal, review or representation to a departmental authority \r\nis provided under the Punjab Civil Servants Act , 1974 (Punjab Act VIII \r\nof 1974), or any rules against any such orders, no appeal shall lie to \r\nthe Tribunal unless the aggrieved per son has preferred an appeal or \r\napplication for review or representation to such departmental auth","quote_sha256":"f1934ff16cbf3985f2572936fc61b5900cfdaa17798220ea9714b8e33dacf4e5","reader_fragment":"p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"}},{"id":"citation-bbeeea8ff31ec40d2175","source":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","target":"pk-code-2fff45df8bbd92f6","target_candidates":["pk-code-2fff45df8bbd92f6"],"resolution":"exact_title_match","relation":"explicit_instrument_citation","evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":4912,"character_end":4941,"quote":"Code of Civil Procedure, 1908","quote_sha256":"262f4a4cb68907827a7a8e7fc81a994947f2057fcee5d9b762e50ed3b433a12c","reader_fragment":"p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"},"context_evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":4742,"character_end":5171,"quote":"\r\n (2) The Tribunal shall, for the purpose of deciding any appeal, be deemed \r\nto be a civil court and shall have the same powers as are vested in such court under \r\nthe Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (Act V of 1908), including the powers of – \r\n(a) enforcing the attendance of any person and examining him on oath; \r\n(b) compelling the production of documents; and \r\n(c) issuing commission for the examination of witnesses and do","quote_sha256":"df6d226e26e84f25e909648201be9c3cf359452ee53fea039b99c4d6282b9fb2","reader_fragment":"p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"}},{"id":"citation-591a7adbe8deb363f44f","source":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","target":null,"target_candidates":["pk-code-53985970d7ba2acd","punjab-code-9c8e1693e64ec530"],"resolution":"ambiguous_source_editions","relation":"explicit_instrument_citation","evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":5404,"character_end":5424,"quote":"Limitation Act, 1908","quote_sha256":"8bf7076509aef86ef0040856fe61fa4a7dd976facd57009d91c6959e0b85d60a","reader_fragment":"p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"},"context_evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":5234,"character_end":5654,"quote":" appeal to, or filing, \r\nexhibiting or recording any document in, or obtaining any document from a Tribunal. \r\n7. Limitation.– The provisions of sections 5 and 12 of the Limitation Act, 1908 (IX \r\nof 1908), shall apply to appeals under this Act. \r\n8. Transfer of appeal .– All appeals pending before the Tribunal established \r\nunder the Punjab Service Tribunal Act , 1974 (Punjab Act VIII of 1974), relating to \r\nmembers","quote_sha256":"48a05af314c04904e31d70cfdbe8d4ee048bcbdae760dee6dfb286036f6ebdcd","reader_fragment":"p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-3477-5259-353c0c110058367d","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"}}],"incoming":[],"internal_references":[{"id":"internal-2a00baf21c86a99d0e02","source":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","target":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","provision_kind":"section","provision_number":"3","qualifier":null,"resolution":"matched_operative_heading","target_evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":1474,"character_end":1488,"quote":"3. Tribunal.– ","quote_sha256":"bdfdde169c6b6ab4f58a8ac4b7378795d0b2c768a9be522c5f26e98f262daff0","reader_fragment":"p-0-1749-2a4ecaee1ef356da","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-0-1749-2a4ecaee1ef356da","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"},"target_fragment":"p-0-1749-2a4ecaee1ef356da","evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":2595,"character_end":2606,"quote":"section \r\n3","quote_sha256":"407cb212f5fc111239e1232b8349e58ba2a719aa7d6ab9532cdecb4ebea20127","reader_fragment":"p-1749-3477-c24aa0e0c002206f","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-1749-3477-c24aa0e0c002206f","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"},"context_evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":2425,"character_end":2836,"quote":"994), w .e.f. 15.10.1991, s.2; and \r\npublished in the Punjab Gazette (Extraordinary), page 107. \r\n4. Constitution of benches .– (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in section \r\n3, the Chairman may constitute a Bench consisting of two Members with or without \r\nthe Chairman and when so constituted, the Bench shall be deemed to be a Tribunal. \r\n(2) If a Bench is unable to arrive at a unanimous decision, in a","quote_sha256":"40b8fae77eef4a84df9158f1212864aaec718e6c4a066d61cbdd4ff5c43156cd","reader_fragment":"p-1749-3477-c24aa0e0c002206f","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-1749-3477-c24aa0e0c002206f","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"}}],"external_references":[],"external_incoming":[],"unresolved":[{"id":"unresolved-07983fdc8f33f22a25cc","source":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","title":"Punjab Service Tribunal Act , 1974","reason":"No unique full-title and year match in this library","evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":5571,"character_end":5605,"quote":"Punjab Service Tribunal Act , 1974","quote_sha256":"6089ba60d244eef06798fc81b932ed1de1389cf937424b606a29a65060758f3c","reader_fragment":"p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"},"context_evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":5401,"character_end":5835,"quote":"he Limitation Act, 1908 (IX \r\nof 1908), shall apply to appeals under this Act. \r\n8. Transfer of appeal .– All appeals pending before the Tribunal established \r\nunder the Punjab Service Tribunal Act , 1974 (Punjab Act VIII of 1974), relating to \r\nmembers of subordinate judiciary shall stand transferred to the Tribunal established \r\nunder this Act. \r\n9. Rules.– The Government may, by notification in the official Gazette, make \r\nrule","quote_sha256":"f597547b7f30b5a2b1b936afbde9b5f7e6b0c06ca7ddbc686b155750aa9f9298","reader_fragment":"p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"}},{"id":"unresolved-48990c85fcf924fc42eb","source":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","title":"Punjab Subordinate Judiciary Service Tribunal Ordinance , 1991","reason":"No unique full-title and year match in this library","evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":5895,"character_end":5957,"quote":"Punjab Subordinate Judiciary Service Tribunal Ordinance , 1991","quote_sha256":"05b7f17739ef714ccc921a9a8c998362965cb102c59e336ab20e1581c6b23cd5","reader_fragment":"p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"},"context_evidence":{"record_id":"punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf","text_version_id":"law:punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf:sha256:b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","text_sha256":"b08f27a837b48ce9cb522f8deb33e45d9035cfe3a877e9cebad7ac23b827a189","character_start":5725,"character_end":5996,"quote":"lished \r\nunder this Act. \r\n9. Rules.– The Government may, by notification in the official Gazette, make \r\nrules for carrying out the purposes of this Act. \r\n10. Repeal.– Punjab Subordinate Judiciary Service Tribunal Ordinance , 1991 \r\n(XVIII of 1991), is hereby repealed.","quote_sha256":"f3aa6fd6757905125b363c6ba53b3d272ea36f0f069b6e2ab3a76d35ac9e8e8a","reader_fragment":"p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","reader_url":"/laws/punjab-code-ab7c23f230bd79cf#p-5259-5996-2a94bf2930a7e223","source_url":"https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/en/show_article/UmcHNAM2V2c-"}}]}